Can Cougars Control Eastern Deer?

by
posted on October 3, 2016
cougars_eastern_deer_f.jpg

Should mountain lions be reintroduced to control expanding deer populations in the East? A recent study released by the University of Washington suggests such a move could be effective, concluding the reintroduction of mountain lions could be a good way to help control whitetail deer populations on the East Coast. According to the New York Times, this latest university study cites there are more than 1.2 million automobile-deer collisions each year, resulting in 200 deaths and $1.66 billion in damages.

While the suggestion is to use the mountain lion as a management tool, hunters and outdoorsmen see potential problems with the use of a management tool that is, by its very nature, unmanageable. The university study calculates that one cat kills 266 deer in its lifetime, and as Western hunters know all too well, mountain lions, like wolves, are opportunistic feeders. Critics of the study say mountain lions will undoubtedly spread into areas where there are no overpopulation problems, creating danger for not only deer herds in those areas, but the human population, livestock and pets as well.

“We agree with what critics of the proposal have said, which is that cost-effective measures such as hunting already exist,” said Susan Recce, director of NRA-ILA Conservation, Wildlife and Natural Resources. “The added bonus: Hunting license fees are used to protect the future of wildlife and account for the primary source of funding for most state wildlife conservation efforts.”

Headed by university scientist Laura R. Prugh, the study analyzed scenarios in 19 states, ultimately excluding Delaware, Illinois, Maryland and Rhode Island for having insufficient habitat to sustain viable populations. While Prugh and her colleagues realize many people would not support the use of lions, a 2015 study by the University of Minnesota and Southern Illinois University Carbondale reported the cats already may be moving east. Regardless of how the cats get there, Prugh says the number of human lives lost due to mountain lions would be far fewer than the number of lives saved through a resulting drop in vehicle-deer collisions.

Latest

LEDE Henry Handguard On White
LEDE Henry Handguard On White

XS Sights Introduces Handguard for Henry Lever-Action Rifles

Designed for modern lever-action enthusiast who want to upgrade their Henry rifle, this highly customizable handguard is equipped with six M-LOK slots on each side and seven on the bottom to accommodate a wide array of accessories.

Montana FWP Announces 2025 Migratory Bird Stamp

A trio of tundra swans winging their way through a gray sky in the shadows of Rocky Mountain peaks is captured brilliantly in the 2025 Montana Migratory Bird Stamp.

Tested: EAA Witness2311 10mm Auto Hunter Pistol

This 2011 double-stack pistol is available with a six-inch barrel and an optics-ready slide for less than you might expect.

New for 2025: Escort Shotguns WS Youth 20-Gauge Shotgun

Youth shotguns are often the first introduction to hunting for many individuals, and Escort Shotguns is looking to help continue that tradition with its WS Youth shotgun.

Busting the Roost Myth: Why You Shouldn't Tree Talk to Toms

Should you call to a roosted tom? Mike Roux fills his readers in on why this popular strategy may be the reason they don't fill all their tags this spring.

Pennsylvania Antlered Deer Harvest Best in Four Decades

Pennsylvania hunters harvested about 11-percent more deer in the 2024-25 hunting seasons than they did the year before, according to Pennsylvania Game Commission estimates released late last month.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.