Studies Show Negative Effect of Talking While Hunting

by
posted on November 7, 2024
Negative Effect Of Talking While Hunting Lead

Remaining quiet when afield is one of hunting’s golden rules, but wildlife biologists are finally statistically modeling the critical role it plays in success. Research featured in a Science Alert story this month—conducted in Africa—found human conversation drove African mammals off watering holes at double the rate of other animal noises, including leopard and lion vocalizations.

The original study results, first released in peer-reviewed Current Biology, determined hunters talking afield will send most animals in flight faster than even gunshots or dogs. “Fear of humans significantly exceeded the fear of lions throughout the savanna mammal community,” researchers wrote. “Considering the community as a whole, wildlife were twice as likely to run, and abandoned waterholes during the dry season in 40 percent faster time, upon hearing humans compared with hearing lions. Critically, this more powerful and all-pervasive response was specifically to hearing human vocalizations, as this differed significantly from all other treatments, whereas the responses to hunting sounds (dogs barking or gunshots) were weaker than, or on a par with, those to lions.”

On a continent with leopards and lions, the results endorse the age-old advice for silence whenever afield. The wisdom also applies to North American deer hunters as well, according to the results of a different study in 2022.

Harnessing a similar recording method, researchers concluded, “Deer were more than twice as likely to flee upon hearing humans than other predators, and hearing humans was matched only by hearing wolves in reducing overall feeding time gaged by visits to the food patch in the following hour.” The reaction to wolf sounds surprised scientists. The study area was in Georgia, no longer home to the predators.

Sportsmen don’t hold an exclusive on the impact, either. Researchers in a study focused on mountain biker and hiker noise, published in July, concluded, “We found wildlife were 3.1–4.7 times more likely to flee and were vigilant for 2.2–3.0 times longer upon hearing recreation noise compared with controls (natural sounds and no noise). Wildlife abundance at our sampling arrays was 1.5 times lower the week following recreation noise deployments. Noise from larger groups of vocal hikers and mountain bikers caused the highest probability of fleeing (6–8 times more likely to flee).”

“Elk were the most sensitive species to recreation noise,” the study determined, “and large carnivores were the least sensitive.” The facts are worth noting if a predator hunt is on your schedule or you plan on carrying a bugle call or two the next time you head afield.

Latest

How To Hunt Safely Into Old Age Lead
How To Hunt Safely Into Old Age Lead

How to Hunt Safely Into Old Age

Hunters armed with the wisdom of age plan for eventualities like ailments, first-aid emergencies and remote communication. Everyone else should heed sage advice if they want to become an old hunter.

Review: Leupold RX-5000 TBR/W

Other than being a tough-as-nails handheld unit that’s touted to range to a maximum of 5,000 yards, the RX-5000 contains “Location Pinning” technology that represents perhaps the biggest advancement for hunters since the laser rangefinder itself.

AR-Platform Rifles Becoming More Common Afield

Forty-one percent of surveyed hunters used an AR-platform rifle at some time for hunting, according to the findings of research conducted by Responsive Management for the Outdoor Stewards of Conservation Foundation.   

#SundayGunday: Taurus Expedition

This week, we’re taking a closer look at the Taurus Expedition, the company’s first-ever bolt-action rifle.

Tips for Moving Your Stand During Deer Season

Hunt long enough and you’ll encounter the need to move a deer stand during the season. Here are some tips for the best ways to do so.

Behind the Bullet: .300 Savage

Having celebrated its 100th birthday in 2020, the .300 Savage remains a sound choice as a big-game cartridge—especially in the woods of the Eastern United States.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.