Thieves Steal $8,500 Decoy Spread from PA Hunter

by
posted on December 12, 2014
dogs_ah2015_fs.jpg (77)

Matt Kneisley of Conestoga, Pa., has hunted his spread of 120 Model 72 Herter decoys for forty years. In an absolutely despicable act, thieves stole 110 of the decoys—carrying an estimated worth of $8,500 and priceless sentimental value—sometime between noon on Thanksgiving Eve and 4 a.m. Thanksgiving morning. The spread was on the Susquehanna River near Peach Bottom, Pa.

"It's bad enough that I lost my Dad this year four months ago, now someone took my decoys we hunted together since I was five years old," Kneisley wrote on Instagram. "Please keep an eye out for anyone selling custom-painted Herters decoys. Bluebills, cans, redheads, mallards and black ducks. Ten floater geese and five V-boards with geese. There is a reward for anyone who helps find the person responsible."

Kneisley routinely left his decoys on the river, saving time (assembling/disassembling 120 cork decoys is no easy task) and allowing him to hunt briefly every day. It's an old school tactic (my father did it) that faded approximately in the '80s due to decoy thieves. However, in four decades Kneisley never ran into trouble.

"I just can't imagine someone going through all that trouble to take that many," Kneisly told Lancaster Online, noting that each decoy was anchored by a 6-pound weight.

The theft is additionally surprising given that Kneisley is well-liked and well-known in the area. He is the Northeast Regional Director of Delta Waterfowl, and he allowed many other hunters to gun his spread. I suspect the thief knew exactly whose decoys he was stealing, and it sickens me to know that someone, somewhere knows where they are.

Folks, these decoys should be easy to spot, as classic Herters are easily recognizable to most waterfowlers. Lancaster Online has a fairly comprehensive photo gallery of Kneisley's stolen blocks. Spread the word. Let's get the poor guy his decoys back.

Latest

Lede A5 Hunter 20 Ga
Lede A5 Hunter 20 Ga

Hardware Review: Browning A5 Hunter 20-Gauge

It’s been forever since the original long-recoil action “Humpback” Auto 5 was conceived by the god of guns, John M. Browning, in 1898, but can you believe how long it’s been since Browning Arms released its “new” A5 after discontinuing the original after a 100-year run?

First Look: Wiley X WX Jakl

Wiley X has introduced its WX Jakl, the latest addition to its Tactical Series of ballistic rated frames.

Recipe: Taiwanese Braised Venison Shank

The shanks off any animal are often undervalued and, in some cases, discarded. However, once you embrace a shank for what it can produce, it can become a special meal worth planning to enjoy.

First Look: CCI Uppercut .22 WMR

The new Uppercut .22 WMR from CCI Ammunition offers rimfire hunters a whole new option for their handguns.

Field Tested: Leupold BX-4 Range HD Gen 2

Philip Massaro tries out Leupold's brand-new rangefinding binocular on a West Texas aoudad hunt. Read on to find out how it performs.

New for 2025: Outdoor Edge Vantex Hunting Knives

The new Outdoor Edge Vantex line of hunting knives has been designed for serious hunters who require serious knives and prefer a traditional fixed-blade design that will last a lifetime.



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.